Shelf Essentials: Best Reads of 2007
Posted by jaytomio on November 17, 2007
First some guidelines and thoughts I had going in to this. I wanted to avoid a couple of aspects I find irritating (and some of which I may have practiced in the past). I’m not going to list a stupid amount of product to try to fit in everything I just ‘liked’ and to make sure I keep people I may happen to like happy, or try to cover all kinds of ground in some effort to showcase a versatile jay-of-all literary trades persona. After all, it’s my favorite dishes, and not intended to be a sampler. Related to that, I’m not going to make a whole bunch of separate categories to hide doing that I said I’m not doing in the prior sentence. I’m not going to give out silly awards, because…well they are silly - and they are yet another way of committing what I was talking about three sentences ago. I’m also not going to differentiate my listing regarding mediums - if it has pages it qualifies, if it’s sweet it’s on this list. I used to have this real strict ‘keep to the year’ policy and for the most part I’m sticking to it, but some 2006 stuff may creep up and maybe even the occasional book I simply missed out. This won’t be some classic of the medium I finally got around to, but will be something maybe that was below the radar in the last couple of years and I just to mention. You should thank me for whippin’ the Delorean out of the garage for a short trip, as in 2007 plutonium is still not sold in every corner drug store - although it may soon be cheaper than gas.
At some point people tend to define what “best reads” means and it always makes me laugh because it seems rather self explanatory. So to tip the scales: nothing listed is guaranteed to improve your life, change your spiritual outlook, make you look smarter for reading, be culturally significant, serve as a source of some hidden enlightenment, a soul moving experience, become misunderstood work of genius, a work before its time, or an innovative genre bending work - and certainly there is no juxtaposing* going on. They may in fact be, some day be, or are and no longer will be by the time you read them, some or all of these things, but for our purposes their sole claim to fame is that I think they’re sweet. Hell, I even had to buy most of this stuff.
The one question of non-relevance is why so early? To get the jump on other sources of opinion? Yes! Because that’s really important to me. No doubt someone will find it irresponsible, but I’d ask people who actually care about such things to take a step back and really think about what they are spending time to comment on - and evaluate what they have become.
There are a few reasons/justifications:
1. The point of these things should be spreading word on good books. What we have to realize is not all people read dozens of books a year and a a lot of these people perhaps get bought books during the holidays or like to have some book while traveling during holiday. Thanks to FBS forumite TK for reminding me.
2. Everybody went to World Fantasy and I’m bored.
3. Looking at books I have lined up, I won’t be reading any other book this year released in 2007. I want to read Valente’s new joint but realistically I don’t see it happening. I ordered it last week, Amazon takes a couple weeks. This is the one book that I’d blindly admit likely would be on this list. Valente rules. This has to be a big deal for her as a writer and I’d like big time publishing to get the message we are ready for this type of work - so lets support this so I have don’t to just be surrounded by Magic the Gathering freaks in my book aisle. I also want to get to Moorcock’s The Metatemporal Detective and I just might get to it in time, but I don’t think so.
I have read quite a few books slated for 2008, but being the founder and only member of RNR** they will be discussed in 2008. There is one book not yet out but you’ll get over it.
So here are the 25 dopest additions to my shelf of 2007. Enjoy, or print if off and commit atrocities to it. The listing order is significant, it could change your life, your spiritual outlook, it will make you look smarter for reading, it is culturally significant, it certainly is a source of some hidden enlightenment, it will move the soul, a clear work of genius, a work before its time (literally), and an innovative list-genre bending work - and it juxtaposes Freudian theology and the social impact of 1980’s Lunch Boxes.
![]()
14. Red Seas Under Red Skies by Scott Lynch
- I realize this came out in July but for me this books came our early in the year and if I can start every year off with a new Lynch book I’m a Robotech live action film away from nirvana, other publishers are scrambling to be fighting for second place early in the years. Two years in a row Lynch set the tone for the year. FBS is in preliminary negotiation (sounds all serious - my herald is taking care of it) to speak to Mr. Lynch very soon so be out on the look out!
My review of Red Seas Under Red Skies.
![]()
9. Shadow Bridge by Gregory Frost
- I have a review/interview set up for December (when the book will be released). This book is the first in a sequence and is a mixture of a bunch of works I love - and the best thing is I don’t know which ones. Should be on every list.
![]()
2. The Yiddish Policeman’s Union by Michael Chabon
- A recent discussion at FBS about the state of the stagnant mystery market reminded me of Chabon, one of our (American) great writers. Looking for innovation any writer of any genre can pull from? Here you go. Anybody who read The Amazing Adventures of Kavalier and Kay, particularly comic fans and haven’t read more are missing out. He didn’t just write a great novel about comics - he’s a great writer who happened to write a great novel about comics.
![]()
7. Elephantmen Volume 1: Wounded Animals (hardcover) by Richard Starkings and Moritat
-Visually this hardcover - that collects the first 11 issues - is out of this world and the presentation is first class. This is a extension of the Hip Flask work. The ‘lack’ of story I have seen some point out exhibit the incompetence of the greater comic/graphic novel review community. Every page is a story and arguably this - along with the related Hip Flask - is the best SF story I read this year.
You know how many - especially comics - books hit a theme and they just get overbearing with it? This touches on many themes and lets it flow.
![]()
1. The Spiral Labyrinth by Matthew Hughes
The best of the Detective/SF/F hybrids I have read recently (and there are a lot of them). This is actually the second book, I’d recommend grabbing Majestrum as well. Reads like a commentary on commentary while never leaving the story; it’s legitimately funny, but not comical.
I think at times Hughes has difficulties closing out novels, but this is a book I really still ponder and may be one of the two or three books I look back on with real fondness this year.
![]()
12. Black Man by Richard Morgan
- Every year you need to read a Science Fiction book about a bad ass coping in PKD’s future - this is 2007’s. I really enjoy his work, but I wasn’t so sure if Morgan was improving with his subsequent books (kind of like how I feel about Reynolds) but I think now his latest is now my favorite.
![]()
24. Grey By Jon Armstrong
- A holdover from my mid-year list. I really like what I said about it then and I’m probably dumber now than I am then so: It’s this versace-grunge SF that has as much substance as style. Upon entering Armstrong’s it takes a moment to get your bearing, not due to an overly fantastic or futuristic departure from what we know, but because the truth surrounds us - and it’s ugly.
![]()
16. 52 By Geoff Johns, Mark Waid, Grant Morrison, Greg Rucka
- Forget the naysayers, the Marvel babies, the people who just can’t live without seeing a character Jim Lee, Tod McFarlane or Rob Liefeld drew in the early 90’s starring in a book, or the tired DC purist who want there DC to remain in that place where nobody wants to read it. We can even forget the people who just want to say it’s an accomplishment just to maintain a weekly schedule on a high profile book. This was the best story in comics to anybody that enjoys actual storylines from the Big 2.
All this crap about examining ‘the corners’ of the DC universe - fuck that - welcome to the DC Universe. Batman, Superman, and Wonder Woman live here to.
4. Under My Roof by Nick Mamatas
- This is a science fiction book, not a horror novel, and kind of replaced my annual Aylett diet for the year but I’m continually intrigued with what I read from Mamatas because more than most he truly comes off as toying and experimenting out of personal interest and sometimes that creates platforms but it’s not the intent it seems to be in the majority of books. Real interesting POV with the protagonist that makes you think similar roles you have read have been missing something.
Soft Skull (the publisher) generally has some awesome books all around.
![]()
15. Binu and the Great Wall: The Myth of Meng by Su Tong
- A late edition here. Su Tong’s My Life as Emperor is one of my favorite all time reads so when I heard about this book I jumped on it like a blind frog.
I’m glad this arrived when it did (and that it isn’t that long). Tong has quickly become one of my favorite writers.
I look forward to all of Cannongate’s Myth series that also include efforts by Ali Smith and Sarah Vickers. Get more info here - this looks sweet.
![]()
25. Artesia Vol 1. (hardcover) by Mark S. Smylie
- Ran from the ASOIAF boards pimps this a lot and this a beautiful product. If you enjoy classic Sword and Sorcery with an incredible depth to history, pantheon etc - this is probably the product to buy because they simply don’t write books like this anymore.
Anyone doing an S&S anthology and isn’t looking at what Smylie is doing is vying for second place. This guy is embarrassing you.
3. One for Sorrow by Chris Barzak
- This book’s major accomplishment is that its written in the interest of relaying a story, not playing a role and you see this most in the portrayal of young emotions and relationships. That is it a debut speak on a couple of things. One, Barzak arrived a long time before he wrote this book, and two somebody at some publisher knows what the fuck they are doing . Review next week.
![]()
19. Image Comics: The Road To Independence George Khoury, Jim Lee, Erik Larsen, Todd McFarlane
- Everybody else is going to have some biography of some obscure mystic or some collection of essays for the one non-fiction spot everyone will have on their lists. Once again you can leave it to me to keep it real. Being my age (called 20-something by people my age) and a comic collector as a kid one of the biggest events in my hobby surrounded formation of Image Comics and the exodus of some of the biggest names in the medium’s history and at that time rock star-like artists to from the two companies who dominated the industry to form their own company.
It’s not going to win a Pulitzer but the comic fan of this era knows the lights were never brighter than it was in this era, this was when comics was big business (I mean a comic book artist was on jean commercials). All eyes were watching in this era, some were blinded and never returned, but it did happen, and it did have impact.
Every list needs to let the author have its indulgences and this mine. I’m almost 30, let me look back on the second full decade of my life with fondness damn it! Plus, I need positive karma for some ammo if I’m going to get Travis Charest to draw the covers for Detective Chimp Absolute edition you will see on E-shelves in 2037 (which will come with a free cloned Chimp).
![]()
5. Orphan’s Tales: In the Night Garden by Catherynne M. Valente
- A late 2006 book that I didn’t get on my 2006 list, but with book II, In the Cities of Coin and Spice, recently released a good time to scoop up both. Possibly my favorite book of the last year. Cat has a few books out but this sequence is on the major publishing tip - and it would be awesome to send the message that we are ready for quality fiction across the board from our favorite fantasy editors and publishers. It’s criminal that this is the stuff that’s trying to break in and find a place. We should expect nothing less, and writer like Valente delivers.
Read my review of Orphan’s Tales: In the Night Garden and check out the interview I conducted with Cat earlier this year.
![]()
22. Fell Vol. 1: Feral City by Warren Ellis and Ben Templesmith
- You wait for this series to drop-off but it doesn’t. It’s without question crafted to be accessible, but once in, Snowtown haunts us beyond issues and becomes something of a novelty: self contained stories features quality writing and art at a nice price point. What the fuck have we become when optimal has morphed into novelty.
You can check out the first issue for free here.
![]()
11. Silverfish by Dave Lapham (hardcover)
- I am just a fan of Lapham. He’s just a creator that if his name is attached I’m buying it, and for some reason the majority of those people aren’t the type of creators who have a constant flow of product hitting the market. Some could all that anti-mainstream (but I like Superman and Batman so that’s dumb), I call it people taking time to put out something that means something.
Along with Simmons’ The Terror (also on this list) are the two works of the year that best establish some sense of fear.
![]()
17. Reapers Gale by Steven Erikson
- Last year for most dedicated fans but some didn’t get this until this year, and honestly I was lukewarm at first. Reading Erikson is not like meeting that girl reminds you of a past fling, but is like that girl you never notices who comes back into town looking thorough that just makes you start thinking of new possibilities with an old form.
Always, in my mind, a top line epic-fantasist, Erikson is more than that. We need to quit talking around it; He’s not an upstart, he is not on parole, we aren’t waiting for him to trip anymore - he is a master.
![]()
20. Saffron and Brimstone: Strange Stories by Elizabeth Hand
- Not a lot of short fiction this year for me, as I have plowed through tons in recent years and frankly with editing Heliotrope I have my yearly fill. It has become apparent over the last few year that no one can truly have too much Liz Hand in their lives however.
You read Liz Hand and you may not love it - but you love the writer. She’s that writer you always thing is on just on the outside looking in every year when people talk about the best books of the year. The Tomio makes no such mistakes and opens the door; have a seat and get comfortable - the collection is lovely - for me she has joined that group this year where I no longer ask, “what book of Hand is out?”. Just knowing there is one answers necessary questions shopping lists may have.
![]()
6. Nightly News by Jonathan Hickman
- What’s going to happen is that comic-commentary hasn’t caught up to the top creators so when you looks this book and read opinions about it you are going to have two reactions.
1. Oh yeah it’s edgy, I’m edgy, I will read it, and we can walk the line together, we will be part of the revolution - everything else sucks!
2. Damn another one of those stupid, hollow edge books that all the people above pose for.
Fuck all that. If you are grown and not a door knob you have read numerous stories with similar themes and elements and done better, but what you have is a just a good story that combines an interesting two-way narrative that has you coming and going at the time with a unique style that combines for a damn welcomed vision.
![]()
8. Children’s Hospital by Chris Adrian
- Wow.
This is my Lydia Millet find this year. A writer who not only has a voice but finds the voices and harmonizes hope and tragedy and leaves us not wanting him to ever shut-up.
![]()
13. The Terror by Dan Simmons
- I think outside of writers like Ligotti, Cisco, and a few others I haven’t seen real horror in decades. That Simmons has more of a presence on the shelf maybe others now can to.
You read The Terror - and you’re alike, “oh yeah, this is what horror is!”. Outside of his Crook Factory this may be my favorite work by Simmons.
![]()
21. Atomik Aztex by Sesshu Foster
- Was released I believe last year and is odd because this books walks the line of being a book I’d almost despise but somehow pulls of a being a must read in a way only a book with Azteks, Nazis, a sacrifices, throw everything at you: alternate history, punk, science fiction, multiple realities, ghosts, - it’ a wild ride that that Foster never loses control of. It’s a rollercoaster that runs over Cortez and the Europe and goes back to the future.
This is the selection that was the most iffy for me and the one I found myself most wanting to replace and in the process I think I got to think about it the most, and it belongs by not belonging.
![]()
23. Tales of the Unexpected: Dr. Thirteen Architecture & Morality by Brian Azzarello and Cliff Chiang
- It’s bullshit that they seem to be collecting this and the story that accompanied it in Tales of the Unexpected separately. The other story was Lapham’s Spectre which was sweet to, but this Azzarello backstory kind of trumps his reputation for being a bit of a one trick (who is a master at that trick) pony. It’s the superior story of the two and the issues themselves were the gems of this year in my mind.
![]()
10. In War Times by Kathleen Ann Goonan
- Admittedly, I don’t make the rounds I usually do but is this book a little underrated coming from a major publisher. I had never read Ms. Goonan’s work before but I will now. The key to quality science fiction is quite simple - don’t bore me to death so I never get past the first 50 pages. I’m a simpleton, I see George come home from work, his flying car folds up into a suitcase, he has a robot maid, he makes sprockets for a living knowing damn well cogs are probably a better product. I understand, I’m ready to move on. I sometimes feel like a form of product placement takes place in a lot of SF and authors feel as if their book may be the first SF the reader has ever picked up - Goonan brings a story. Thank you. Let me the figure the rest out for myself.
So much of the the often asinine (and way over-linked) opinion on ‘world building’ brought up relates to Fantasy, and a certain branch of it - but SF authors have fell into this to except most of them are not very good at it. More Chiang, more Wright, more Justine - SF is a feeling for me not a place.
![]()
18. Epitaph for a Tramp and Epitaph for a Dead Beat by David Markson
- Again I have been doing my dabbling in crime/mystery and I love it when I find writers in the field who apparently have read other books. It is evident even in this edition that collects two books written by Markson in 1959 and 1961. They follow the exploits of PI Harry Fannin and display a gift for narrative and surrounding culture (existing not steamed) that would later make him one of the most anticipated novelists in fiction.
Epilogue:
The Road was treated as an understood list occupant (late 2006 book).
For a few years now, I am continually amazed at the variety of product out there and this incredible competence in publisher acquisitions. It almost feels like an Order 66 was implemented and old fogies were replaced with people with a clue. It’s why I have no more angst, there is nothing to complain about. That’s part of the reason some sources have become obsolete to me (indeed why I have***), it seems changes have been made. I’m all for gripe, but shit I’m not going to look for shit to gripe about. It’s time to put down the bullhorn and step out of unrealized time and smell the smaragdine hued heliotropes. From Flower Punk to Hack and Slash, from Latro to Skywalker, it’s all love on the Tomio Shelf.
Extreme props to the Star Wars gang working on Legacy of the Force: Aaron Allston, Karen Traviss, Troy Denning. I can’t pick one and while there have always been good SW novels - this is the first time in a long time they felt like they mattered. Really looking forward to reading on and it’s awesome that in a Post-prequel world, we can say that about Star Wars.
* Just stop it, it’s over saturated, you never use it in real life - why play the role online? This goes for DVD commentary participants as well. Knock it off!
**Reviewing not racing
***an example of revising history













November 17, 2007 at 2:31 pm
[...] Link to: Best Reads of 2007 [...]
November 17, 2007 at 3:50 pm
It looks like I’m a forumite that needs to add to his Christmas list. My time at the in-laws is looking better already.
November 17, 2007 at 5:15 pm
An excellent list, particularly as you’ve got some excellent taste in graphic novels.
I’ve got Silverfish waiting to be read (and damn it, someone give Lapham a grant so he can get back to doing Stray Bullets) , and right now I’m checking Artesia Online periodically to find out when Smylie will dig himself out from under his publishing work to get the next issue in the Artesia series out.
November 17, 2007 at 6:49 pm
Thanks!
Regarding Smylie I had read his TPB before and it was awesome but the presentation and quality of these hardcover are just awesome, even breathtaking.
I’m not at all saying this is some kind of sign, I don’t know Lapham or have any info on the state of Lapham’s projects, but over the last few months he has started to sell his original artwork (there is a a damn sweet Rai cover for sale now), which is not something that was usual before. I definitely hope to see more Lapham work no matter who its for. I have always been a huge fan - ever since I saw the glory of Harbinger#1.
November 17, 2007 at 7:04 pm
[...] Check it out! While looking through the blogosphere we stumbled on an interesting post today.Here’s a quick excerptShelf Essentials: Best Reads of 2007 Posted by jaytomio on November 17, 2007 First some guidelines and thoughts I had going in to this. I wanted to avoid a couple of aspects I find irritating (and some of which I may have practiced in the past). I’m not going to list a stupid amount of product to try to fit in everything I just ‘liked’ and to make sure I keep people I may happen to like happy, or try to cover all kinds of ground in some effort to showcase a versatile jay-of-all literary trade [...]
November 19, 2007 at 5:31 am
Quick question, is Elephantmen Volume 1: Wounded Animals collection oversized like the Marvel OSHCs or is it just a regular hardcover?
November 19, 2007 at 5:34 am
Nice list there, Jay, even though I’ll disagree on a few (namely, I found the Lynch to be a step down from the first one, but perhaps a re-read in a year or two will improve my opinion of it…maybe, but I’m not holding my breath). I am curious to see what you’ll make of Cisco’s latest novel, The Traitor, if/when you read it.
Have you given any consideration to writing a 2007 Turds recap of the books you most disliked for 2007? I think that would be an interesting read there. And in totally unrelated news, thanks for recommending to me Abe’s [i]The Woman in the Dunes[/i]. I finally got around to reading it a couple of weeks ago and shall be looking for more of his work in the coming months. Almost good enough to talk me into learning some Japanese in order to be able to try to tackle his works in the original, which is about the highest praise I’ll give a non-English release!
November 19, 2007 at 9:06 am
Larry,
I think Lynch’s second novel because although we knew where it was going (or not going from the end of the first) I thought it was pretty bold. He could have mailed in another Camor novel but didn’t and while some instances seemed almost - I don’t know - somewhat exposed to being prolonged there were times like his visit to get his chairs crafted that really went well for me.
Regarding Traitor, next year/late this year I intend to get back to some form of monthly review schedule - thus if they don’t send it I’m not reviewing it. On the surface that seems pretty mercish of me (but no different from any other source either) but I have (more than) enough people who do send me books and I feel if I review anything (whether positively or negatively) it should come from that pool. I don’t have Traitor thus I have to assume I’m not getting it - although I do love Cisco’s works and will probably buy and read it.
Regarding a list of what sucked - I just don’t see the point. I have no qualms with reviewing a book negatively (or pointing out negative aspects in a review) or even commenting on a book indirectly, but making a list/post dedicated to panning books seems like something I’d have problems getting motivated for. It goes from sharing experiences to being intentionally snarky. I don’t think I have ever seen such a piece done that was at all useful, and I think I’ll leave that to the people that don’t have anything to really say to act like they do. That, and I have become quite adept at picking what books to read. Certainly I run into books I don’t care much for, but they are really in the minority and only occur if I binge on debut writers. I can usually avoid something completely awful - and in truth I like to think I bypass most that would be on such a list. I don’t have to read the latest Goodkind to figure out I won’t enjoy it. So basically I would be sharing a bunch of books that were good, just not what I felt were the best, and I figure there are enough lists out there that will cover those. I think I really have to the point where the brilliant and completely awful are few far between and most everything else are incomplete parts and a mixture of both.
I think I grabbed on to Abe after seeing Jeffrey Ford recommend the novel
Noel - Is the Planet Hulk and oversized HC? If so it’s slightly bigger in width and length (I’d say an inch each way or so)
November 19, 2007 at 7:26 pm
Jay,
I think my issue with the second Lynch deals more with my personal expectations in seeing more overt change in the characters as well as my dislike for most any stories set at sea (I was pleasantly surprised by Wolfe’s Pirate Freedom for mostly avoiding the faux-pirate jargon, which I despise with a passion). I suspect a re-read later will improve my opinion of it, but for now, it wasn’t a book that I enjoyed as much as the first or as much as I could have hoped to have done after reading the first. Perhaps it’s just as simple as expecting/wanting one thing and Lynch needing for the story to go another.
As far as the negative reviews, I personally am much the same as you. I know what I like and dislike and outside of reading some of those review copies sent to me, I typically spend a lot of time “researching” an author to see if his/her style is good, if the characters “breathe,” and if the plot develops in a logical fashion. But yet I have a defined audience (wotmania) and I find myself having to take them into account, since they’re reading my reviews to judge for themselves to see if a work is worth buying. I know it’s caveat emptor or something like that in regards to buying/reading off of another’s rec, but finding that balance in what to praise and what to condemn is tricky, as the Lynch comment above might illustrate. I was disappointed by the book and said so, but if I had completely trashed it, would that have impacted a few readers who might otherwise have bought and enjoyed it?
I know I shouldn’t have such thoughts in my mind when I review, but my personal review philosophy has been to consider multiple perspectives in regards to some works. Sometimes a negative review by another helps me to evaluate a work and to adjust my expectations to where I don’t get unrealistic hopes for a particular work. But yes, just trashing a book just to trash it isn’t worth it, since that too would detract from the very real purpose of reviewing. I’ll have to think some more on this, since my Best of 2007 list will be coming out next month and I know I’ll have a small section devoted to the books that didn’t quite click with me.
November 20, 2007 at 9:32 am
I think a piece on ‘most disappointing’ is more plausible. As I said before, I have no qualms about a negative review, but find writing a piece to highlight a group of lackluster works to be a bit different entity altogether.
December 10, 2007 at 12:35 pm
[...] Shelf Essentials: Best Reads of 2007 [...]
December 31, 2007 at 10:31 pm
[...] Adventures in Reading - The Wertzone - Pat’s Fantasy Hotlist - The Bodhisattva - Grasping for the Wind - Fantasy Book Critic - Graeme’s Fantasy Book Review - OF blog of the [...]
March 29, 2008 at 4:38 pm
[...] I put in on my Best of 2007 List so, I can’t start fronting now. It does make me feel I missed out on some books as I [...]